Aguilar dismisses new Trump impeachment bid

 April 30, 2025

Rep. Pete Aguilar, the chair of the House Democratic Caucus, firmly dismissed the idea of pursuing a third impeachment of former President Donald Trump, arguing that it would be fruitless and urging Democrats to concentrate instead on addressing pressing policy issues.

According to Washington Examiner, Aguilar's remarks align with other Democratic leaders who view the notion of impeachment as both politically risky and lacking bipartisan support.

During a discussion with reporters on Tuesday, Aguilar highlighted the futility of pursuing impeachment against Trump again, citing the improbability of garnering support from Republican lawmakers in both the House and the Senate. Aguilar pointed out that Republicans' lack of willingness to act in previous impeachment efforts against Trump indicated that a third attempt would yield similar results.

Focus Shifts to Policy Over Impeachment

Alongside Aguilar, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer also refrained from endorsing impeachment initiatives, cautioning that such actions could backfire politically. Schumer and other Democrats have referred to impeachment efforts as "stupid politics," preferring to direct their focus on matters that resonate more with their constituents.

Aguilar specifically mentioned healthcare and nutrition as areas where Democrats should concentrate their legislative efforts. He expressed confidence that addressing these issues would better serve the American public than engaging in what he views as a divisive act of impeachment.

While Aguilar took a stand against impeachment, Rep. Shri Thanedar initiated impeachment articles accusing Trump of abuses of power, constitutional violations, and tyranny. Thanedar's actions were mirrored by Rep. Al Green's advocacy for impeachment in a Congress currently dominated by Republicans.

The Historical Context of Trump's Impeachments

Trump had previously been impeached twice by the House: first in 2019 and subsequently in January 2021. Yet, both times, the Senate acquitted him, rendering the impeachment efforts ultimately futile in removing him from office.

Despite this historical context, a White House spokesperson criticized Democrats' recent push for impeachment, calling it a "reckless political act" that neglects the "safety, security, and well-being of hardworking American citizens." The spokesperson's statement highlighted a perceived prioritization of political gamesmanship over substantive governance.

Meanwhile, Trump's political allies are advocating for actions that aim to energize their base and bolster economic policies. John McLaughlin, an ally of Trump, emphasized the necessity of passing tax cuts to avoid a recession, underscoring the high political stakes as the midterm elections approach.

Democratic Concerns About Impeachment's Impact

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has sounded alarms about potential impeachment proceedings if Democrats regain control of the House in future elections. Bessent's remarks suggest concerns about the possible swift move to impeach Trump as soon as political leverage shifts.

Aguilar, however, is steering clear of such discussions, choosing instead to focus on tools that are immediately actionable and relevant to current challenges. "Right now, we will deal with the tools in front of us," Aguilar remarked, emphasizing a more pragmatic approach to governance.

Ultimately, the divide within the Democratic ranks underscores the complexity of balancing political strategy with legislative priorities. While some members, like Aguilar, advocate for a focus on tangible policies, others remain committed to holding Trump accountable through impeachment.

Strategy Tensions Within Democratic Party

The rhetoric suggests an ongoing debate over the best approach to achieving Democratic goals and addressing constituents' needs. This tension is reflective of broader strategic concerns as the midterm elections loom on the horizon.

Aguilar's perspective is clear: impeachment is only a viable tool when there is confidence in bipartisan support, which he asserts is lacking in the current political climate. His disinterest in pursuing what he deems a "stunt" aligns with his focus on advancing policy priorities.

As Democrats navigate the complexities of governing in a divided political landscape, the contrasting viewpoints within the party illustrate diverse opinions on effective resistance strategies and the best path forward.